NEWS ALERT - We won a SILVER IPM award for Best use of Social Media, 2025! Read more🏆

What does register is a stranger on the internet saying "I've had mine for two years and it's still going strong". Or a friend saying "don't bother, it broke after a month". Or a two-star review that goes into detail about a delivery that never turned up.
There's a growing gap between what brands say about themselves and what people are prepared to believe. Closing it isn't about finding better words for the same claims. It's about giving other people good reasons to make the case for you.
Think of it as the claim gap: the distance between what a brand says and what customers accept as true.
It exists because people know how marketing works. They know the advert was written by the brand, the product shot was lit by a professional and the "customer favourite" badge was chosen by the marketing team. None of that makes it dishonest. It just makes it expected, and expected messages get discounted.
A review from another customer carries no such baggage. That person has nothing to sell. They bought the product with their own money and are reporting back. It's the same reason we ask colleagues for restaurant tips rather than reading the restaurant's own website.
This is more than a feel-good point about authenticity. Trust has become a hard commercial factor.
The 2026 Edelman Trust Barometer special report on brands, which surveyed more than 17,000 people across 15 countries, found that 88% say trusting a brand is an important or critical factor when they buy. That puts trust on a par with quality (89%) and value (88%). The same report points to earned endorsement from customers and peers as more powerful than anything a brand says about itself.
Reviews show the same pattern. BrightLocal's 2026 Local Consumer Review Survey found that 97% of consumers read reviews for local businesses and 49% trust them as much as personal recommendations from people they know. Expectations are rising too. The share of consumers who will only use a business rated four stars or higher rose from 55% in 2025 to 68% in 2026.
A few things make peer voices so persuasive.
They're specific. An advert says "long-lasting". A review says "I've washed it forty times and the colour hasn't faded". Detail feels like evidence.
They include the negatives. Real reviews mention what isn't perfect, and that makes the positives more believable. Research from the Spiegel Research Center at Northwestern University found that purchase likelihood tends to peak for products rated between 4.2 and 4.5 stars, then drops as ratings get closer to a perfect five. A flawless score can look too good to be true.
They come from people like us. We're more likely to believe someone whose situation matches our own. A parent recommending a pushchair to another parent carries weight that no brand spokesperson can match.
They feel unrehearsed. A creator talking to camera in their own kitchen doesn't sound like a script, even when there's a partnership behind it. Handled properly, that ease is what makes creator content work.
For a while, some brands tried to short-cut the process with paid-for reviews, suspiciously glowing testimonials and quietly buried complaints. In the UK that door is now firmly shut.
Since 6 April 2025, the Digital Markets, Competition and Consumers Act has banned fake reviews and concealed incentivised reviews, as well as presenting reviews in a misleading way, such as suppressing negative ones. Businesses that break the rules can face fines of up to 10% of global turnover, and platforms that publish reviews have to take reasonable steps to stop fakes.
That's good news for brands playing fair. It means credibility has to be earned the slow way, which is also the only way it lasts.
If the most persuasive voices belong to your customers, the job is to give them something worth talking about and make it easy for them to say it.
Deliver on the basics first. No amount of marketing can outrun a product that disappoints. The quickest way to better reviews is a better experience.
Ask for reviews, then get out of the way. Plenty of happy customers never leave a review simply because nobody asked. A well-timed, low-effort request helps. Scripting what they say doesn't.
Reply to the bad ones too. A calm, helpful response to a complaint shows future customers how you behave when things go wrong. People often trust a brand more after seeing a problem handled well.
Put proof where decisions are made. Reviews, ratings and customer photos belong on product pages, packaging, adverts and social content, not tucked away in a separate section.
Work with creators who would use you anyway. The best partnerships feel like a recommendation because they are one. The "Trusted by the Best" campaign for Tate & Lyle Sugars is a good example, with professional bakers talking in their own words about how they use the product.
Listen as much as you speak. What customers say about you in reviews, forums and comments is some of the most useful research you'll ever get, and it's free.
Brands will always need to tell their own story. Advertising builds awareness and memory in ways that reviews can't. But when it comes to convincing people, a brand's own voice is now just one voice among many, and rarely the most trusted.
The brands that win credibility are the ones that accept this rather than fight it. They make products worth recommending, give customers room to be candid, and treat every review, reply and recommendation as part of the brand.
After all, anyone can say they're good. It means a lot more when someone else says it for you.
At Together, we help brands close the gap between what they say and what people believe, through creator partnerships, social content and campaigns built around real voices. If you'd like more people talking about your brand for the right reasons, let's start a conversation.
Why do consumers trust reviews more than advertising?
Reviews come from people with nothing to sell, they tend to be specific, and they include negatives as well as positives. That makes them feel like evidence, whereas advertising is expected to be positive and is often discounted.
Are fake reviews illegal in the UK?
Yes. Since 6 April 2025, the Digital Markets, Competition and Consumers Act has banned fake reviews, concealed incentivised reviews and misleading presentation of reviews. Breaches can lead to fines of up to 10% of global turnover.
How can brands build credibility with consumers?
Deliver a strong product experience, ask customers for reviews without scripting them, respond openly to criticism, show real proof where people make decisions, and partner with creators who would recommend the brand anyway.